NCT07008209

Comparing the Effectiveness of Reappraisal Strategies in Adult Participants

Comparing the Effects of Reconstrual and Repurposing Reappraisal Strategies on Sadness and Anxiety in Emerging Adults: A Brief Intervention

• Status: Completed
• Phase: N/A
• Study type: Interventional
• Enrollment: 233 (actual)
• Sponsor: Ibn Haldun University · Academic / Other
• Sex: All
• Age: 18 Years – 30 Years
• Healthy volunteers: Accepted

Summary

The goal of this clinical trial is to learn which reappraisal strategy works better to reduce sadness and anxiety in emerging adults. The main questions it aims to answer are: What is the effect of emotion regulation strategies (reconstrual, repurposing) on short term negative emotions (anxiety, sadness)? Does the effectiveness of these strategies vary depending on the type of emotion (anxiety vs. sadness)? Are reconstrual and repurposing more effective compared to active and passive control conditions? What is the effect of these strategies on short-term positive emotions (e.g., hope, happiness)? Researchers will compare reconstrual and repurposing strategies to see which one is more effective in improving emotional outcomes. Participants will: be randomly assigned to one of eight conditions in a 4 (Regulation Strategy: Reconstrual, Repurposing, Active Control, Passive Control) × 2 (Emotion Type: Sadness vs. Anxiety) factorial design. Complete online tasks and surveys about their emotions

Detailed description

This study evaluates the effectiveness of two cognitive reappraisal strategies-reconstrual (reinterpreting the meaning of an event) and repurposing (modifying the personal goal related to the event)-in reducing negative affect and enhancing positive affect in response to emotion-evoking scenarios in emerging adults. Participants (at least N = 240) will be randomly assigned to one of eight groups in a 2 (Emotion: Sadness vs. Anxiety) × 4 (Strategy: Reconstrual, Repurposing, Active Control, Passive Control) between-subjects factorial design. Each participant will complete standardized emotional induction tasks via written scenarios, followed by their assigned intervention. Hypotheses H1: Negative emotions (sadness or anxiety) will significantly decrease following the intervention in the reconstrual and repurposing groups compared to the active and passive control groups. (Main effect of strategy on negative affect) H2: Positive emotions will increase more in the reconstrual and repurposing groups compared to the passive control group. (Main effect of strategy on positive affect) H3 (Exploratory): The effectiveness of reconstrual and repurposing strategies may vary by emotion type: Repurposing may be more effective in sadness scenarios. Reconstrual may be more effective in anxiety scenarios. (Emotion Type × Strategy interaction) H4: No significant emotional change is expected in the passive control group. (No time effect) Study Design Design Type: Experimental, between-subjects factorial design Design Structure: 2 (Emotion Type: Sadness vs. Anxiety) × 4 (Strategy Condition: Reconstrual, Repurposing, Active Control, Passive Control) Participants: Minimum N = 240 (n = 30 per group), emerging adults (ages \~18-30) Randomization: Random assignment to 1 of 8 groups Blinding: Participants are blind to condition purpose Type of Analysis: Mixed ANOVA Within-Subject Factor: Time (Post-Scenario vs. Post-Intervention) Between-Subject Factors: Emotion Type × Strategy Group Dependent Variables: Emotional ratings post-intervention (Negative affect (VAS/SAM: anxiety, sadness); Positive affect (VAS/SAM). Study Flow 1. Initial Assessment Demographics: Only name and age Baseline measures: Scale for contextual reappraisal (SCORE; for trait-level reconstrual and repurposing), GAD-7, PHQ-9 2. Neutral Stimulus A standardized neutral video from Samson et al. (2016) study. 3. Baseline Emotion Assesments: Self-Assessment Manikin (SAM), Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) 4. Random Group Assignment Participants randomly assigned to one of eight groups (n=30 per group): Sadness - Reconstrual Sadness - Repurposing Sadness - Active Control Sadness - Passive Control Anxiety - Reconstrual Anxiety - Repurposing Anxiety - Active Control Anxiety - Passive Control 5. Training Phase Strategy-specific training with a minimum 90-second reading time enforced Practice vignette with 30-second enforced reading and comprehension check Correct answers allow progression; incorrect answers trigger explanation and acknowledgment before continuing Participants rate prior use of the trained strategy in daily life 6. Scenario Exposure Participants read and imagine a standardized written scenario (sadness or anxiety) matched for intensity and controllability (based on pilot data) 40-second enforced reading time 7\. Self-Assessment and Rating VAS and SAM administered Ratings of scenario imaginability and controllability (0-100 scale) Participants write their first negative thoughts when imagining the scenario 8\. Application Phase Participants apply assigned emotion regulation strategy with 90-second minimum enforced duration Written brief explanation of alternative thoughts used Post-application ratings with VAS and SAM Participants rate effectiveness and belief in their reappraisal thoughts (0-100 scale) 9\. Manipulation Check In the form of two multiple-choice questions: Participants will be asked to select the instruction that best matched the guideline they received at the beginning of the experiment and to identify the general topic of the scenario they had visualized. 10\. Demographics: Exclusion criteria related questions 11. Debriefing Participants view debriefing statement

Conditions

• Emotional Dysregulation
• Anxiety
• Sadness
• Anxiety Disorders and Symptoms
• Depressive Symptoms

Interventions

Type	Name	Description
BEHAVIORAL	Reconstrual Strategy Training	Participants receive training in the reconstrual strategy, which involves recognizing and reinterpreting initial negative appraisals of emotionally challenging situations. The training guides participants to: Identify the situation and their initial negative interpretation. Generate alternative, balanced explanations that reduce negative emotional impact. The goal is to help participants view events from a different, realistic perspective to decrease negative emotions by modifying how they interpret situations.
BEHAVIORAL	Repurposing Strategy Training	Participants receive training in the repurposing strategy, which involves adjusting or replacing personal goals to better align with the current situation. The training guides participants to: Identify the situation and the original goal that was not met. Develop alternative, realistic goals or modify existing ones to reduce the emotional impact of unmet expectations. This approach helps participants manage negative emotions by creating meaningful, adaptable goals that fit the reality of the situation.
BEHAVIORAL	Active Control	Participants are asked to carefully copy a neutral descriptive passage without making any changes, focusing solely on transcription accuracy. This task serves as an active control by engaging participants in a cognitive task that requires attention and effort, but does not involve emotion regulation strategies. The task controls for the effects of engagement and time spent on a task without influencing participants' emotional processing.

Timeline

• Start date: 2025-09-21
• Primary completion: 2026-01-05
• Completion: 2026-01-10
• First posted: 2025-06-06
• Last updated: 2026-03-27

Locations

1 site across 1 country: Turkey (Türkiye)